| Year | W/L/T | Team | PF | Opponent | PA | Location | Notes |
| 1924 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Indiana St. | 47 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1924 | L | Ball State (IN) | 2 | Indianapolis (IN) | 13 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1924 | W | Ball State (IN) | 9 | Central Normal (IN) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1924 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Earlham (IN) | 21 | Richmond, IN | |
| 1925 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Wabash (IN) | 67 | Crawfordsville, IN | |
| 1925 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Central Normal (IN) | 12 | Danville, IN | |
| 1925 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Indianapolis (IN) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1925 | W | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Manchester (IN) | 7 | North Manchester, IN | |
| 1925 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Indiana St. | 20 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1925 | W | Ball State (IN) | 32 | Union Christian College (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1925 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Earlham (IN) | 20 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1926 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Wabash (IN) | 43 | Crawfordsville, IN | |
| 1926 | W | Ball State (IN) | 35 | Indianapolis (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1926 | W | Ball State (IN) | 19 | Manchester (IN) | 3 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1926 | T | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Central Normal (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1926 | W | Ball State (IN) | 54 | Oakland City (IN) | 7 | Oakland City, IN | |
| 1926 | W | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Hanover (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1926 | W | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Earlham (IN) | 0 | Richmond, IN | |
| 1927 | L | Ball State (IN) | 12 | Butler (IN) | 46 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1927 | W | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Franklin (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1927 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Central Normal (IN) | 18 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1927 | T | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Indianapolis (IN) | 13 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1927 | W | Ball State (IN) | 32 | Oakland City (IN) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1927 | W | Ball State (IN) | 43 | Cedarville (OH) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1927 | W | Ball State (IN) | 12 | Hanover (IN) | 6 | Madison, IN | |
| 1927 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Defiance (OH) | 19 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1928 | W | Ball State (IN) | 52 | Concordia (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1928 | T | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Franklin (IN) | 6 | Franklin, IN | |
| 1928 | T | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Indianapolis (IN) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1928 | W | Ball State (IN) | 12 | Central Normal (IN) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1928 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Butler (IN) | 12 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1928 | W | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Hanover (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1928 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | DePauw (IN) | 19 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1929 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Indianapolis (IN) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1929 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Western Kentucky | 13 | Bowling Green, KY | |
| 1929 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Franklin (IN) | 12 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1929 | L | Ball State (IN) | 12 | Central Normal (IN) | 14 | Danville, IN | |
| 1929 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Indiana JV | 27 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1929 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Notre Dame JV (IN) | 81 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1929 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | DePauw (IN) | 46 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1930 | W | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Valparaiso (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1930 | W | Ball State (IN) | 34 | Oakland City (IN) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1930 | W | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Central Normal (IN) | 0 | Danville, IN | |
| 1930 | W | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Wabash (IN) | 12 | Crawfordsville, IN | |
| 1930 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Manchester (IN) | 13 | North Manchester, IN | |
| 1930 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Franklin (IN) | 0 | Franklin, IN | |
| 1930 | W | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Indianapolis (IN) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1931 | W | Ball State (IN) | 12 | Central Normal (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1931 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Miami (OH) | 47 | Oxford, OH | |
| 1931 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Butler (IN) | 34 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1931 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Wabash (IN) | 21 | Crawfordsville, IN | |
| 1931 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Manchester (IN) | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1931 | W | Ball State (IN) | 22 | Earlham (IN) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1931 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Indiana St. | 13 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1931 | L | Ball State (IN) | 12 | Franklin (IN) | 26 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1932 | L | Ball State (IN) | 12 | Butler (IN) | 13 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1932 | W | Ball State (IN) | 26 | Earlham (IN) | 12 | Richmond, IN | |
| 1932 | W | Ball State (IN) | 18 | Central Normal (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1932 | W | Ball State (IN) | 34 | Oakland City (IN) | 12 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1932 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Franklin (IN) | 13 | Franklin, IN | |
| 1932 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Manchester (IN) | 20 | North Manchester, IN | |
| 1932 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Valparaiso (IN) | 20 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1932 | W | Ball State (IN) | 12 | Indiana St. | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1933 | L | Ball State (IN) | 2 | Butler (IN) | 19 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1933 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | DePauw (IN) | 9 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1933 | W | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Central Normal (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1933 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Valparaiso (IN) | 20 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1933 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Manchester (IN) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1933 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Indiana St. | 9 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1933 | T | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Franklin (IN) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1933 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Hanover (IN) | 20 | Hanover, IN | |
| 1934 | L | Ball State (IN) | 4 | Butler (IN) | 13 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1934 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Central Normal (IN) | 0 | Danville, IN | |
| 1934 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | DePauw (IN) | 13 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1934 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Franklin (IN) | 6 | Franklin, IN | |
| 1934 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Valparaiso (IN) | 30 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1934 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Manchester (IN) | 13 | North Manchester, IN | |
| 1934 | W | Ball State (IN) | 15 | Indiana St. | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1934 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Hanover (IN) | 19 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1935 | W | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Franklin (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1935 | W | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Central Normal (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1935 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Valparaiso (IN) | 20 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1935 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | DePauw (IN) | 14 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1935 | W | Ball State (IN) | 25 | Oakland City (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1935 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Indiana St. | 12 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1935 | T | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Manchester (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1935 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Hanover (IN) | 20 | Hanover, IN | |
| 1936 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Eastern Michigan | 6 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1936 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Central Normal (IN) | 25 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1936 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Indiana St. | 3 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1936 | W | Ball State (IN) | 12 | Franklin (IN) | 0 | Franklin, IN | |
| 1936 | W | Ball State (IN) | 40 | Oakland City (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1936 | T | Ball State (IN) | 0 | DePauw (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1936 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Manchester (IN) | 21 | North Manchester, IN | |
| 1936 | W | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Hanover (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1937 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Eastern Michigan | 13 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1937 | W | Ball State (IN) | 52 | Oakland City (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1937 | W | Ball State (IN) | 26 | Central Normal (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1937 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | DePauw (IN) | 13 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1937 | W | Ball State (IN) | 12 | Hanover (IN) | 0 | Hanover, IN | |
| 1937 | W | Ball State (IN) | 26 | Manchester (IN) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1937 | W | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Indiana St. | 0 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1937 | T | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Franklin (IN) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1938 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Butler (IN) | 12 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1938 | W | Ball State (IN) | 26 | Central Normal (IN) | 0 | Danville, IN | |
| 1938 | W | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Indiana St. | 9 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1938 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Manchester (IN) | 14 | North Manchester, IN | |
| 1938 | T | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 13 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1938 | W | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Valparaiso (IN) | 0 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1938 | W | Ball State (IN) | 19 | Hanover (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1938 | W | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Earlham (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1939 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Butler (IN) | 16 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1939 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Grand Rapids (MI) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1939 | W | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1939 | W | Ball State (IN) | 29 | Indiana St. | 6 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1939 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Central Michigan | 7 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 1939 | W | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Earlham (IN) | 13 | Richmond, IN | |
| 1939 | W | Ball State (IN) | 16 | Valparaiso (IN) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1939 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Manchester (IN) | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1940 | T | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Miami (OH) | 0 | Oxford, OH | |
| 1940 | W | Ball State (IN) | 12 | DeSales (OH) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1940 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Central Michigan | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1940 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Manchester (IN) | 7 | North Manchester, IN | |
| 1940 | W | Ball State (IN) | 26 | Valparaiso (IN) | 0 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1940 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Central Normal (IN) | 2 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1940 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Butler (IN) | 26 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1940 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Indiana St. | 27 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1941 | T | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Northern Illinois | 6 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1941 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Butler (IN) | 13 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1941 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Central Michigan | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1941 | W | Ball State (IN) | 40 | Valparaiso (IN) | 0 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1941 | T | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Manchester (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1941 | W | Ball State (IN) | 33 | Central Normal (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1941 | W | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Indiana St. | 0 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1942 | W | Ball State (IN) | 38 | Franklin (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1942 | W | Ball State (IN) | 34 | Central Normal (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1942 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Bowling Green (OH) | 26 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1942 | W | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Northern Illinois | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1942 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Central Michigan | 19 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 1942 | W | Ball State (IN) | 28 | Manchester (IN) | 6 | North Manchester, IN | |
| 1942 | W | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Valparaiso (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1942 | W | Ball State (IN) | 16 | Indiana St. | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1944 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Central Normal (IN) | 13 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1944 | W | Ball State (IN) | 19 | Franklin (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1944 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Central Normal (IN) | 25 | Danville, IN | |
| 1944 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Earlham (IN) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1945 | W | Ball State (IN) | 28 | Central Normal (IN) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1945 | W | Ball State (IN) | 29 | Franklin (IN) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1945 | T | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Wabash (IN) | 0 | Crawfordsville, IN | |
| 1945 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Valparaiso (IN) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1945 | W | Ball State (IN) | 40 | Earlham (IN) | 6 | Richmond, IN | |
| 1945 | W | Ball State (IN) | 16 | Butler (IN) | 2 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1946 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Canterbury (IN) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1946 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Bowling Green (OH) | 13 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 1946 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Wabash (IN) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1946 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Valparaiso (IN) | 6 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1946 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Butler (IN) | 20 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1946 | W | Ball State (IN) | 41 | Manchester (IN) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1946 | T | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Eastern Michigan | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1946 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Indiana St. | 3 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1947 | T | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Butler (IN) | 6 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1947 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Eastern Illinois | 13 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1947 | W | Ball State (IN) | 18 | Valparaiso (IN) | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1947 | T | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1947 | W | Ball State (IN) | 9 | Anderson (IN) | 0 | Anderson, IN | |
| 1947 | W | Ball State (IN) | 19 | Manchester (IN) | 0 | North Manchester, IN | |
| 1947 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Eastern Michigan | 14 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1947 | W | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Indiana St. | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1948 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 33 | Rensselaer, IN | |
| 1948 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Eastern Illinois | 12 | Charleston, IL | |
| 1948 | W | Ball State (IN) | 53 | Huntington (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1948 | W | Ball State (IN) | 23 | Eastern Michigan | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1948 | W | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Anderson (IN) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1948 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Valparaiso (IN) | 0 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1948 | W | Ball State (IN) | 35 | Manchester (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1948 | W | Ball State (IN) | 10 | Indiana St. | 7 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1949 | W | Ball State (IN) | 28 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1949 | W | Ball State (IN) | 33 | DePauw (IN) | 13 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1949 | W | Ball State (IN) | 35 | Anderson (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1949 | W | Ball State (IN) | 33 | Eastern Michigan | 2 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1949 | W | Ball State (IN) | 16 | Valparaiso (IN) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1949 | W | Ball State (IN) | 50 | Manchester (IN) | 7 | North Manchester, IN | |
| 1949 | W | Ball State (IN) | 34 | Indiana St. | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1949 | W | Ball State (IN) | 47 | Eastern Illinois | 13 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1950 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Eastern Illinois | 35 | Charleston, IL | |
| 1950 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | DePauw (IN) | 13 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1950 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Butler (IN) | 33 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1950 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Eastern Michigan | 13 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1950 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Valparaiso (IN) | 21 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1950 | T | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 7 | Rensselaer, IN | |
| 1950 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Indiana St. | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1951 | L | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Evansville (IN) | 35 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1951 | L | Ball State (IN) | 19 | Wabash (IN) | 34 | Crawfordsville, IN | |
| 1951 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | DePauw (IN) | 14 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1951 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Butler (IN) | 20 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1951 | T | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Indiana St. | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1951 | L | Ball State (IN) | 12 | Valparaiso (IN) | 34 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1951 | L | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 39 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1952 | T | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Hanover (IN) | 7 | Hanover, IN | |
| 1952 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Eastern Michigan | 26 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1952 | L | Ball State (IN) | 25 | DePauw (IN) | 40 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1952 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Butler (IN) | 28 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1952 | W | Ball State (IN) | 33 | Indiana St. | 0 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1952 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Valparaiso (IN) | 14 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1952 | W | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 6 | Rensselaer, IN | |
| 1952 | L | Ball State (IN) | 19 | Wabash (IN) | 39 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1952 | W | Ball State (IN) | 26 | Evansville (IN) | 7 | Evansville, IN | |
| 1953 | T | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Hanover (IN) | 13 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1953 | W | Ball State (IN) | 19 | Millikin (IL) | 13 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1953 | W | Ball State (IN) | 28 | DePauw (IN) | 7 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1953 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Butler (IN) | 25 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1953 | W | Ball State (IN) | 33 | Indiana St. | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1953 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Valparaiso (IN) | 27 | Michigan City, IN | |
| 1953 | W | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 6 | Rensselaer, IN | |
| 1953 | W | Ball State (IN) | 42 | Evansville (IN) | 28 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1954 | W | Ball State (IN) | 40 | Hanover (IN) | 6 | Hanover, IN | |
| 1954 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Millikin (IL) | 7 | Decatur, IL | |
| 1954 | W | Ball State (IN) | 40 | DePauw (IN) | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1954 | W | Ball State (IN) | 26 | Butler (IN) | 13 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1954 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Indiana St. | 14 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1954 | L | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Valparaiso (IN) | 46 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1954 | W | Ball State (IN) | 26 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1954 | W | Ball State (IN) | 25 | Evansville (IN) | 7 | Evansville, IN | |
| 1955 | W | Ball State (IN) | 39 | Hanover (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1955 | W | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Indiana (PA) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1955 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | DePauw (IN) | 19 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1955 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Butler (IN) | 20 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1955 | W | Ball State (IN) | 19 | Indiana St. | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1955 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Valparaiso (IN) | 26 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1955 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 28 | Rensselaer, IN | |
| 1955 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Evansville (IN) | 38 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1956 | W | Ball State (IN) | 12 | Hanover (IN) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1956 | W | Ball State (IN) | 26 | Indiana (PA) | 0 | Indiana, PA | |
| 1956 | W | Ball State (IN) | 19 | DePauw (IN) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1956 | L | Ball State (IN) | 12 | Butler (IN) | 28 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1956 | W | Ball State (IN) | 28 | Indiana St. | 14 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1956 | L | Ball State (IN) | 12 | Valparaiso (IN) | 49 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1956 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 66 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1956 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Evansville (IN) | 33 | Evansville, IN | |
| 1957 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Hanover (IN) | 34 | Hanover, IN | |
| 1957 | L | Ball State (IN) | 12 | Illinois St. | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1957 | T | Ball State (IN) | 26 | Valparaiso (IN) | 26 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1957 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Evansville (IN) | 13 | Evansville, IN | |
| 1957 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | DePauw (IN) | 40 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1957 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Butler (IN) | 27 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1957 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 55 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1957 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Indiana St. | 0 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1957 | W | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Illinois St. | 14 | Normal, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Valparaiso (IN) | 6 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Wooster (OH) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Ball State (IN) | 35 | Evansville (IN) | 16 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | DePauw (IN) | 6 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Butler (IN) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 6 | Rensselaer, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Ball State (IN) | 26 | Indiana St. | 8 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1959 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Illinois St. | 22 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1959 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Valparaiso (IN) | 24 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1959 | L | Ball State (IN) | 8 | Eastern Illinois | 14 | Charleston, IL | |
| 1959 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Evansville (IN) | 10 | Evansville, IN | |
| 1959 | W | Ball State (IN) | 30 | DePauw (IN) | 24 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1959 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Butler (IN) | 27 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1959 | L | Ball State (IN) | 8 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 22 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1959 | L | Ball State (IN) | 8 | Indiana St. | 29 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1960 | L | Ball State (IN) | 3 | Illinois St. | 7 | Normal, IL | |
| 1960 | L | Ball State (IN) | 8 | Valparaiso (IN) | 10 | Fort Wayne, IN | |
| 1960 | W | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Eastern Illinois | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1960 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Evansville (IN) | 10 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1960 | W | Ball State (IN) | 24 | DePauw (IN) | 20 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1960 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Butler (IN) | 27 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1960 | W | Ball State (IN) | 23 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 7 | Rensselaer, IN | |
| 1960 | L | Ball State (IN) | 23 | Indiana St. | 26 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1961 | T | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Eastern Michigan | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1961 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Butler (IN) | 48 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1961 | L | Ball State (IN) | 8 | DePauw (IN) | 10 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1961 | W | Ball State (IN) | 8 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 0 | Rensselaer, IN | |
| 1961 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Indiana St. | 41 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1961 | L | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Valparaiso (IN) | 28 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1961 | W | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Evansville (IN) | 3 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1961 | L | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Ohio Northern | 49 | Ada, OH | |
| 1962 | W | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Eastern Michigan | 0 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1962 | T | Ball State (IN) | 28 | Butler (IN) | 28 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1962 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | DePauw (IN) | 7 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1962 | W | Ball State (IN) | 15 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1962 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Indiana St. | 22 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1962 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Valparaiso (IN) | 21 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1962 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Evansville (IN) | 7 | Evansville, IN | |
| 1962 | W | Ball State (IN) | 42 | Bradley (IL) | 22 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1963 | W | Ball State (IN) | 22 | Eastern Michigan | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1963 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Butler (IN) | 13 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1963 | W | Ball State (IN) | 15 | DePauw (IN) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1963 | W | Ball State (IN) | 23 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 0 | Rensselaer, IN | |
| 1963 | W | Ball State (IN) | 15 | Indiana St. | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1963 | L | Ball State (IN) | 40 | Valparaiso (IN) | 48 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1963 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Evansville (IN) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1963 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Bradley (IL) | 28 | Peoria, IL | |
| 1964 | W | Ball State (IN) | 26 | Slippery Rock (PA) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1964 | W | Ball State (IN) | 28 | Butler (IN) | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1964 | W | Ball State (IN) | 23 | DePauw (IN) | 20 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1964 | W | Ball State (IN) | 38 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1964 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Indiana St. | 17 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1964 | L | Ball State (IN) | 22 | Valparaiso (IN) | 33 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1964 | W | Ball State (IN) | 23 | Evansville (IN) | 16 | Evansville, IN | |
| 1964 | L | Ball State (IN) | 15 | Akron (OH) | 25 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1965 | W | Ball State (IN) | 26 | Indiana (PA) | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1965 | W | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Valparaiso (IN) | 6 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1965 | W | Ball State (IN) | 42 | Evansville (IN) | 13 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1965 | W | Ball State (IN) | 16 | Akron (OH) | 14 | Akron, OH | |
| 1965 | W | Ball State (IN) | 51 | DePauw (IN) | 29 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1965 | W | Ball State (IN) | 22 | Butler (IN) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1965 | W | Ball State (IN) | 52 | Indiana St. | 15 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1965 | W | Ball State (IN) | 42 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 19 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1965 | W | Ball State (IN) | 30 | Southern Illinois | 19 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1965 | T | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Tennessee St. | 14 | Murfreesboro, TN | Grantland Rice Bowl |
| 1966 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Indiana (PA) | 7 | Indiana, PA | |
| 1966 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Valparaiso (IN) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1966 | T | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Evansville (IN) | 21 | Evansville, IN | |
| 1966 | L | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Northern Illinois | 38 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1966 | W | Ball State (IN) | 30 | DePauw (IN) | 15 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1966 | W | Ball State (IN) | 17 | Butler (IN) | 14 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1966 | W | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Indiana St. | 20 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1966 | W | Ball State (IN) | 29 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 16 | Rensselaer, IN | |
| 1966 | W | Ball State (IN) | 15 | Southern Illinois | 14 | Carbondale, IL | |
| 1967 | W | Ball State (IN) | 41 | Central Missouri St. | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1967 | W | Ball State (IN) | 39 | Valparaiso (IN) | 7 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1967 | W | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Evansville (IN) | 10 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1967 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Northern Illinois | 28 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1967 | W | Ball State (IN) | 7 | DePauw (IN) | 3 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1967 | W | Ball State (IN) | 65 | Butler (IN) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1967 | W | Ball State (IN) | 26 | Indiana St. | 24 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1967 | L | Ball State (IN) | 2 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1967 | W | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Southern Illinois | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1967 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Eastern Kentucky | 27 | Murfreesboro, TN | Grantland Rice Bowl |
| 1968 | L | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Northern Illinois | 40 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1968 | L | Ball State (IN) | 8 | Bowling Green (OH) | 62 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 1968 | W | Ball State (IN) | 26 | Valparaiso (IN) | 11 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1968 | W | Ball State (IN) | 26 | Evansville (IN) | 3 | Evansville, IN | |
| 1968 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Eastern Michigan | 43 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1968 | W | Ball State (IN) | 17 | DePauw (IN) | 12 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1968 | W | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Butler (IN) | 21 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1968 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Indiana St. | 20 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1968 | W | Ball State (IN) | 47 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 6 | Rensselaer, IN | |
| 1969 | W | Ball State (IN) | 10 | Buffalo (NY) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1969 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Eastern Kentucky | 13 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1969 | W | Ball State (IN) | 36 | Butler (IN) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1969 | L | Ball State (IN) | 9 | Akron (OH) | 49 | Akron, OH | |
| 1969 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Indiana St. | 26 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1969 | W | Ball State (IN) | 38 | Evansville (IN) | 0 | Evansville, IN | |
| 1969 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Northern Illinois | 17 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1969 | W | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Middle Tennessee St. | 12 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1969 | L | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Southern Illinois | 48 | Carbondale, IL | |
| 1969 | W | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Eastern Michigan | 22 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1970 | W | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Buffalo (NY) | 7 | Buffalo, NY | |
| 1970 | L | Ball State (IN) | 12 | Eastern Kentucky | 13 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1970 | W | Ball State (IN) | 26 | Butler (IN) | 13 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1970 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Akron (OH) | 31 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1970 | W | Ball State (IN) | 28 | Indiana St. | 26 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1970 | W | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Evansville (IN) | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1970 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Northern Illinois | 31 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1970 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Middle Tennessee St. | 14 | Murfreesboro, TN | |
| 1970 | W | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Southern Illinois | 17 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1970 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Eastern Michigan | 60 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1971 | W | Ball State (IN) | 9 | Central Michigan | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1971 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Western Michigan | 9 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1971 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Butler (IN) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1971 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Akron (OH) | 10 | Akron, OH | |
| 1971 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Indiana St. | 17 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1971 | L | Ball State (IN) | 8 | Southern Illinois | 33 | Carbondale, IL | |
| 1971 | T | Ball State (IN) | 10 | Northern Illinois | 10 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1971 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Middle Tennessee St. | 28 | Murfreesboro, TN | |
| 1971 | W | Ball State (IN) | 28 | Wittenberg (OH) | 21 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1971 | L | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Western Illinois | 21 | Macomb, IL | |
| 1972 | W | Ball State (IN) | 30 | Central Michigan | 12 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1972 | W | Ball State (IN) | 50 | Butler (IN) | 41 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1972 | T | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Akron (OH) | 21 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1972 | W | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Indiana St. | 10 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1972 | W | Ball State (IN) | 28 | Dayton (OH) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1972 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Southern Illinois | 13 | Carbondale, IL | |
| 1972 | W | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Middle Tennessee St. | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1972 | L | Ball State (IN) | 17 | Western Illinois | 21 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1972 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Western Michigan | 31 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1972 | L | Ball State (IN) | 23 | Illinois St. | 24 | Normal, IL | |
| 1973 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Eastern Michigan | 17 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1973 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Central Michigan | 14 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 1973 | W | Ball State (IN) | 52 | Butler (IN) | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1973 | W | Ball State (IN) | 16 | Akron (OH) | 14 | Akron, OH | |
| 1973 | W | Ball State (IN) | 18 | Indiana St. | 17 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1973 | L | Ball State (IN) | 12 | Dayton (OH) | 13 | Dayton, OH | |
| 1973 | L | Ball State (IN) | 17 | Northern Illinois | 45 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1973 | W | Ball State (IN) | 34 | Middle Tennessee St. | 3 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1973 | T | Ball State (IN) | 16 | Southern Illinois | 16 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1973 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Western Michigan | 30 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1973 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Illinois St. | 18 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1974 | L | Ball State (IN) | 17 | Central Michigan | 24 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1974 | W | Ball State (IN) | 45 | Butler (IN) | 0 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1974 | L | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Akron (OH) | 26 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1974 | L | Ball State (IN) | 22 | Indiana St. | 31 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1974 | W | Ball State (IN) | 38 | Richmond (VA) | 23 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1974 | W | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Youngstown St. (OH) | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1974 | L | Ball State (IN) | 9 | Eastern Michigan | 17 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1974 | W | Ball State (IN) | 43 | Middle Tennessee St. | 14 | Murfreesboro, TN | |
| 1974 | W | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Northern Illinois | 21 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1974 | W | Ball State (IN) | 18 | Illinois St. | 7 | Normal, IL | |
| 1975 | W | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Eastern Michigan | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1975 | W | Ball State (IN) | 38 | Toledo (OH) | 28 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1975 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Ohio | 10 | Athens, OH | |
| 1975 | L | Ball State (IN) | 28 | Miami (OH) | 35 | Oxford, OH | |
| 1975 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Indiana St. | 16 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1975 | W | Ball State (IN) | 25 | Richmond (VA) | 14 | Richmond, VA | |
| 1975 | W | Ball State (IN) | 16 | Central Michigan | 13 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1975 | W | Ball State (IN) | 3 | Northern Illinois | 0 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1975 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Bowling Green (OH) | 20 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 1975 | W | Ball State (IN) | 17 | Akron (OH) | 14 | Akron, OH | |
| 1975 | W | Ball State (IN) | 46 | Illinois St. | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1976 | W | Ball State (IN) | 41 | Louisiana Tech | 28 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1976 | W | Ball State (IN) | 23 | Miami (OH) | 6 | Oxford, OH | |
| 1976 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Toledo (OH) | 14 | Toledo, OH | |
| 1976 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Dayton (OH) | 13 | Dayton, OH | |
| 1976 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Illinois St. | 10 | Normal, IL | |
| 1976 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Akron (OH) | 3 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1976 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Appalachian St. (NC) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1976 | W | Ball State (IN) | 33 | Northern Illinois | 7 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1976 | W | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Indiana St. | 9 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1976 | L | Ball State (IN) | 10 | Western Michigan | 24 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1976 | W | Ball State (IN) | 52 | Eastern Michigan | 3 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1977 | W | Ball State (IN) | 43 | Toledo (OH) | 3 | Toledo, OH | |
| 1977 | L | Ball State (IN) | 16 | Villanova (PA) | 38 | Villanova, PA | |
| 1977 | L | Ball State (IN) | 12 | Kent St. (OH) | 13 | Kent, OH | |
| 1977 | W | Ball State (IN) | 28 | Central Michigan | 12 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1977 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Illinois St. | 16 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1977 | W | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Northern Illinois | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1977 | W | Ball State (IN) | 66 | Cal Poly-Pomona | 10 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1977 | W | Ball State (IN) | 38 | Appalachian St. (NC) | 7 | Boone, NC | |
| 1977 | W | Ball State (IN) | 42 | Indiana St. | 18 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1977 | W | Ball State (IN) | 29 | Western Michigan | 25 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1977 | W | Ball State (IN) | 45 | Eastern Michigan | 21 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1978 | W | Ball State (IN) | 38 | Miami (OH) | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1978 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Kent St. (OH) | 3 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1978 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Toledo (OH) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1978 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Central Michigan | 0 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 1978 | W | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Indiana St. | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1978 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Louisiana Tech | 17 | Ruston, LA | |
| 1978 | W | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Illinois St. | 7 | Normal, IL | |
| 1978 | W | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Eastern Michigan | 0 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1978 | W | Ball State (IN) | 39 | Bowling Green (OH) | 14 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 1978 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Western Michigan | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1978 | W | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Northern Illinois | 13 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1979 | L | Ball State (IN) | 3 | Miami (OH) | 27 | Oxford, OH | |
| 1979 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Toledo (OH) | 31 | Toledo, OH | |
| 1979 | W | Ball State (IN) | 35 | Kent St. (OH) | 10 | Kent, OH | |
| 1979 | W | Ball State (IN) | 17 | Southeastern Louisiana | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1979 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Indiana St. | 18 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1979 | W | Ball State (IN) | 42 | Illinois St. | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1979 | L | Ball State (IN) | 30 | Central Michigan | 31 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1979 | W | Ball State (IN) | 38 | Bowling Green (OH) | 23 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1979 | W | Ball State (IN) | 28 | Eastern Michigan | 10 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1979 | L | Ball State (IN) | 10 | Western Michigan | 20 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1979 | W | Ball State (IN) | 42 | Northern Illinois | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1980 | L | Ball State (IN) | 17 | Central Michigan | 21 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 1980 | W | Ball State (IN) | 18 | Northern Illinois | 17 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1980 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Toledo (OH) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1980 | L | Ball State (IN) | 9 | Miami (OH) | 42 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1980 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | McNeese St. (LA) | 24 | Lake Charles, LA | |
| 1980 | W | Ball State (IN) | 26 | Eastern Michigan | 0 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1980 | L | Ball State (IN) | 15 | Western Michigan | 17 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1980 | L | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Bowling Green (OH) | 24 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 1980 | W | Ball State (IN) | 34 | Kent St. (OH) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1980 | W | Ball State (IN) | 37 | Ohio | 18 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1980 | W | Ball State (IN) | 28 | Indiana St. | 21 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1981 | W | Ball State (IN) | 24 | McNeese St. (LA) | 21 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1981 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Toledo (OH) | 40 | Toledo, OH | |
| 1981 | L | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Ohio | 30 | Athens, OH | |
| 1981 | W | Ball State (IN) | 23 | Northern Illinois | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1981 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Indiana St. | 31 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1981 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Kent St. (OH) | 17 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1981 | L | Ball State (IN) | 3 | Western Michigan | 14 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1981 | W | Ball State (IN) | 35 | Eastern Michigan | 13 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1981 | L | Ball State (IN) | 10 | Bowling Green (OH) | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1981 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Central Michigan | 28 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1981 | W | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Illinois St. | 10 | Normal, IL | |
| 1982 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Toledo (OH) | 31 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1982 | L | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Wichita St. (KS) | 33 | Wichita, KS | |
| 1982 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Indiana St. | 17 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1982 | W | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Northern Illinois | 7 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1982 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Ohio | 34 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1982 | W | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Kent St. (OH) | 3 | Kent, OH | |
| 1982 | W | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Western Michigan | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1982 | W | Ball State (IN) | 16 | Eastern Michigan | 7 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1982 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Bowling Green (OH) | 28 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 1982 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Central Michigan | 24 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 1982 | W | Ball State (IN) | 52 | Illinois St. | 17 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1983 | W | Ball State (IN) | 42 | Rhode Island | 26 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1983 | W | Ball State (IN) | 25 | Wichita St. (KS) | 21 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1983 | W | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Ohio | 14 | Athens, OH | |
| 1983 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Toledo (OH) | 43 | Toledo, OH | |
| 1983 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Northern Illinois | 27 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1983 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Indiana St. | 35 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1983 | W | Ball State (IN) | 17 | Kent St. (OH) | 13 | Kent, OH | |
| 1983 | W | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Western Michigan | 20 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1983 | W | Ball State (IN) | 33 | Eastern Michigan | 20 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1983 | L | Ball State (IN) | 30 | Bowling Green (OH) | 45 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 1983 | L | Ball State (IN) | 10 | Central Michigan | 38 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1984 | L | Ball State (IN) | 10 | Massachusetts | 26 | Amherst, MA | |
| 1984 | L | Ball State (IN) | 2 | Toledo (OH) | 20 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1984 | L | Ball State (IN) | 17 | Ohio | 31 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1984 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Washington St. | 16 | Pullman, WA | |
| 1984 | W | Ball State (IN) | 15 | Northern Illinois | 14 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1984 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Indiana St. | 34 | Indianapolis, IN | Played at Hoosier Dome |
| 1984 | L | Ball State (IN) | 10 | Kent St. (OH) | 15 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1984 | W | Ball State (IN) | 23 | Western Michigan | 20 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1984 | W | Ball State (IN) | 17 | Eastern Michigan | 10 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1984 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Bowling Green (OH) | 38 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1984 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Central Michigan | 51 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 1985 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Bowling Green (OH) | 31 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1985 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Miami (OH) | 17 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1985 | L | Ball State (IN) | 18 | Purdue (IN) | 37 | West Lafayette, IN | |
| 1985 | W | Ball State (IN) | 23 | Toledo (OH) | 19 | Toledo, OH | |
| 1985 | W | Ball State (IN) | 29 | Northern Illinois | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1985 | W | Ball State (IN) | 36 | Ohio | 23 | Athens, OH | |
| 1985 | L | Ball State (IN) | 16 | Kent St. (OH) | 45 | Kent, OH | |
| 1985 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Western Michigan | 34 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1985 | L | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Eastern Michigan | 27 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1985 | W | Ball State (IN) | 29 | Indiana St. | 27 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1985 | L | Ball State (IN) | 9 | Central Michigan | 23 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1986 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Northern Illinois | 10 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1986 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Miami (OH) | 45 | Oxford, OH | |
| 1986 | L | Ball State (IN) | 3 | Purdue (IN) | 20 | West Lafayette, IN | |
| 1986 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Toledo (OH) | 10 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1986 | W | Ball State (IN) | 16 | Indiana St. | 3 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1986 | W | Ball State (IN) | 30 | Ohio | 9 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1986 | W | Ball State (IN) | 26 | Kent St. (OH) | 17 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1986 | W | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Western Michigan | 10 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1986 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Eastern Michigan | 14 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1986 | L | Ball State (IN) | 17 | Bowling Green (OH) | 20 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 1986 | L | Ball State (IN) | 22 | Central Michigan | 43 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 1987 | L | Ball State (IN) | 17 | Toledo (OH) | 21 | Toledo, OH | |
| 1987 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Bowling Green (OH) | 24 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1987 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Wisconsin | 30 | Madison, WI | |
| 1987 | L | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Miami (OH) | 30 | Oxford, OH | |
| 1987 | W | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Kent St. (OH) | 23 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1987 | L | Ball State (IN) | 28 | Eastern Michigan | 35 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1987 | W | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Central Michigan | 3 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1987 | W | Ball State (IN) | 42 | Northern Illinois | 17 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1987 | L | Ball State (IN) | 16 | Western Michigan | 31 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1987 | W | Ball State (IN) | 30 | Ohio | 17 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1987 | L | Ball State (IN) | 23 | Indiana St. | 24 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1988 | W | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Toledo (OH) | 3 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1988 | W | Ball State (IN) | 34 | Bowling Green (OH) | 10 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 1988 | W | Ball State (IN) | 44 | Massachusetts | 17 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1988 | W | Ball State (IN) | 45 | Miami (OH) | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1988 | W | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Kent St. (OH) | 20 | Kent, OH | |
| 1988 | L | Ball State (IN) | 12 | Eastern Michigan | 16 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1988 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Central Michigan | 20 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 1988 | W | Ball State (IN) | 18 | Northern Illinois | 17 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1988 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Western Michigan | 16 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1988 | L | Ball State (IN) | 25 | Ohio | 27 | Athens, OH | |
| 1988 | W | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Indiana St. | 10 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1989 | L | Ball State (IN) | 10 | West Virginia | 35 | Morgantown, WV | |
| 1989 | T | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Rutgers (NJ) | 31 | New Brunswick, NJ | |
| 1989 | W | Ball State (IN) | 28 | Bowling Green (OH) | 3 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 1989 | L | Ball State (IN) | 22 | Toledo (OH) | 29 | Toledo, OH | |
| 1989 | W | Ball State (IN) | 37 | Miami (OH) | 9 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1989 | W | Ball State (IN) | 23 | Kent St. (OH) | 21 | Kent, OH | |
| 1989 | W | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Western Michigan | 13 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1989 | W | Ball State (IN) | 34 | Indiana St. | 27 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1989 | T | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Central Michigan | 13 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1989 | W | Ball State (IN) | 23 | Eastern Michigan | 17 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1989 | W | Ball State (IN) | 33 | Ohio | 14 | Athens, OH | |
| 1989 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Fresno St. (CA) | 27 | Fresno, CA | California Bowl |
| 1990 | W | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Illinois St. | 3 | Normal, IL | |
| 1990 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Wisconsin | 24 | Madison, WI | |
| 1990 | L | Ball State (IN) | 16 | Toledo (OH) | 28 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1990 | W | Ball State (IN) | 16 | Bowling Green (OH) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1990 | L | Ball State (IN) | 10 | Miami (OH) | 24 | Oxford, OH | |
| 1990 | W | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Kent St. (OH) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1990 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Western Michigan | 14 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1990 | W | Ball State (IN) | 42 | Indiana St. | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1990 | W | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Central Michigan | 3 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 1990 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Eastern Michigan | 13 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1990 | W | Ball State (IN) | 23 | Ohio | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1991 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Miami (OH) | 15 | Oxford, OH | |
| 1991 | W | Ball State (IN) | 33 | Navy (MD) | 10 | Annapolis, MD | |
| 1991 | L | Ball State (IN) | 16 | Texas Christian | 22 | Fort Worth, TX | |
| 1991 | W | Ball State (IN) | 28 | Kent St. (OH) | 27 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1991 | W | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Indiana St. | 10 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1991 | L | Ball State (IN) | 16 | Western Michigan | 25 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1991 | W | Ball State (IN) | 10 | Eastern Michigan | 8 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1991 | L | Ball State (IN) | 3 | Central Michigan | 10 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 1991 | W | Ball State (IN) | 10 | Ohio | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1991 | W | Ball State (IN) | 9 | Toledo (OH) | 3 | Toledo, OH | |
| 1991 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Bowling Green (OH) | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1992 | L | Ball State (IN) | 10 | Clemson (SC) | 24 | Clemson, SC | |
| 1992 | L | Ball State (IN) | 10 | Kansas | 62 | Lawrence, KS | |
| 1992 | W | Ball State (IN) | 10 | Kent St. (OH) | 6 | Kent, OH | |
| 1992 | W | Ball State (IN) | 19 | Miami (OH) | 9 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1992 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Western Michigan | 21 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1992 | W | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Eastern Michigan | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1992 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Akron (OH) | 22 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1992 | W | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Central Michigan | 23 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1992 | W | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Ohio | 21 | Athens, OH | |
| 1992 | L | Ball State (IN) | 9 | Toledo (OH) | 10 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1992 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Bowling Green (OH) | 38 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 1993 | L | Ball State (IN) | 12 | Syracuse (NY) | 35 | Syracuse, NY | |
| 1993 | W | Ball State (IN) | 45 | Illinois St. | 30 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1993 | W | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Ohio | 16 | Athens, OH | |
| 1993 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Central Michigan | 17 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 1993 | W | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Toledo (OH) | 30 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1993 | L | Ball State (IN) | 12 | Cincinnati (OH) | 44 | Cincinnati, OH | |
| 1993 | T | Ball State (IN) | 26 | Bowling Green (OH) | 26 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1993 | W | Ball State (IN) | 18 | Eastern Michigan | 13 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1993 | W | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Miami (OH) | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1993 | W | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Akron (OH) | 9 | Akron, OH | |
| 1993 | W | Ball State (IN) | 28 | Kent St. (OH) | 3 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1993 | L | Ball State (IN) | 33 | Utah St. | 42 | Las Vegas, NV | Las Vegas Bowl |
| 1994 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | West Virginia | 16 | Morgantown, WV | |
| 1994 | L | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Purdue (IN) | 49 | West Lafayette, IN | |
| 1994 | W | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Ohio | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1994 | W | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Central Michigan | 28 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1994 | T | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Toledo (OH) | 24 | Toledo, OH | |
| 1994 | W | Ball State (IN) | 16 | Western Michigan | 13 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1994 | L | Ball State (IN) | 36 | Bowling Green (OH) | 59 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 1994 | L | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Eastern Michigan | 41 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1994 | L | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Miami (OH) | 24 | Oxford, OH | |
| 1994 | W | Ball State (IN) | 38 | Akron (OH) | 28 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1994 | W | Ball State (IN) | 34 | Kent St. (OH) | 0 | Kent, OH | |
| 1995 | W | Ball State (IN) | 17 | Miami (OH) | 15 | Oxford, OH | |
| 1995 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Western Illinois | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1995 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Minnesota | 31 | Minneapolis, MN | |
| 1995 | W | Ball State (IN) | 10 | Western Michigan | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1995 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Purdue (IN) | 35 | West Lafayette, IN | |
| 1995 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Toledo (OH) | 17 | Toledo, OH | |
| 1995 | W | Ball State (IN) | 30 | Bowling Green (OH) | 10 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1995 | L | Ball State (IN) | 35 | Eastern Michigan | 40 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1995 | W | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Ohio | 3 | Athens, OH | |
| 1995 | W | Ball State (IN) | 28 | Kent St. (OH) | 13 | Kent, OH | |
| 1995 | W | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Central Michigan | 16 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1996 | L | Ball State (IN) | 10 | Kansas | 35 | Lawrence, KS | |
| 1996 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Miami (OH) | 16 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1996 | L | Ball State (IN) | 23 | Minnesota | 26 | Minneapolis, MN | |
| 1996 | W | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Central Florida | 10 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1996 | W | Ball State (IN) | 28 | Western Michigan | 5 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1996 | W | Ball State (IN) | 30 | Ohio | 27 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1996 | W | Ball State (IN) | 16 | Bowling Green (OH) | 11 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 1996 | W | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Central Michigan | 17 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 1996 | W | Ball State (IN) | 39 | Eastern Michigan | 25 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1996 | W | Ball State (IN) | 50 | Kent St. (OH) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1996 | W | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Toledo (OH) | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1996 | L | Ball State (IN) | 15 | Nevada | 18 | Las Vegas, NV | Las Vegas Bowl |
| 1997 | L | Ball State (IN) | 10 | Miami (OH) | 27 | Oxford, OH | |
| 1997 | W | Ball State (IN) | 24 | James Madison (VA) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1997 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Indiana | 33 | Bloomington, IN | |
| 1997 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Purdue (IN) | 28 | West Lafayette, IN | |
| 1997 | L | Ball State (IN) | 16 | Marshall (WV) | 42 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1997 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Western Michigan | 21 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1997 | L | Ball State (IN) | 32 | Eastern Michigan | 38 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1997 | W | Ball State (IN) | 37 | Central Michigan | 34 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1997 | W | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Northern Illinois | 14 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1997 | W | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Akron (OH) | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1997 | W | Ball State (IN) | 35 | Toledo (OH) | 3 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1998 | L | Ball State (IN) | 20 | South Carolina | 38 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1998 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Eastern Michigan | 13 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1998 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Iowa St. | 38 | Ames, IA | |
| 1998 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Akron (OH) | 52 | Akron, OH | |
| 1998 | W | Ball State (IN) | 18 | Northern Illinois | 13 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1998 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Toledo (OH) | 27 | Toledo, OH | |
| 1998 | L | Ball State (IN) | 17 | Miami (OH) | 28 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1998 | L | Ball State (IN) | 10 | Marshall (WV) | 42 | Huntington, WV | |
| 1998 | L | Ball State (IN) | 23 | Western Michigan | 24 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1998 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Central Florida | 37 | Orlando, FL | |
| 1998 | L | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Central Michigan | 31 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 1998 | L | Ball State (IN) | 9 | Indiana | 21 | Bloomington, IN | |
| 1999 | L | Ball State (IN) | 10 | Wisconsin | 50 | Madison, WI | |
| 1999 | L | Ball State (IN) | 10 | Toledo (OH) | 23 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1999 | L | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Army (NY) | 41 | West Point, NY | |
| 1999 | L | Ball State (IN) | 9 | Akron (OH) | 31 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1999 | L | Ball State (IN) | 17 | Northern Illinois | 37 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1999 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Western Michigan | 28 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1999 | L | Ball State (IN) | 25 | Ohio | 37 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1999 | L | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Eastern Michigan | 31 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1999 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Bowling Green (OH) | 35 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 1999 | L | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Central Michigan | 27 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2000 | L | Ball State (IN) | 19 | Florida | 40 | Gainesville, FL | |
| 2000 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Western Illinois | 24 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2000 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Kansas St. | 76 | Manhattan, KS | |
| 2000 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Northern Illinois | 43 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2000 | W | Ball State (IN) | 15 | Miami (OH) | 10 | Oxford, OH | |
| 2000 | W | Ball State (IN) | 33 | Eastern Michigan | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2000 | W | Ball State (IN) | 44 | Buffalo (NY) | 35 | Buffalo, NY | |
| 2000 | W | Ball State (IN) | 38 | Central Michigan | 34 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 2000 | L | Ball State (IN) | 3 | Western Michigan | 42 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2000 | L | Ball State (IN) | 3 | Toledo (OH) | 31 | Toledo, OH | |
| 2000 | W | Ball State (IN) | 29 | Connecticut | 0 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2001 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Auburn (AL) | 30 | Auburn, AL | |
| 2001 | L | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Kentucky | 28 | Lexington, KY | |
| 2001 | L | Ball State (IN) | 39 | Northern Iowa | 42 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2001 | L | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Miami (OH) | 28 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2001 | W | Ball State (IN) | 35 | Eastern Michigan | 14 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 2001 | W | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Toledo (OH) | 20 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2001 | W | Ball State (IN) | 10 | Connecticut | 5 | Storrs, CT | |
| 2001 | W | Ball State (IN) | 38 | Central Michigan | 34 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2001 | L | Ball State (IN) | 18 | Kent St. (OH) | 31 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2001 | L | Ball State (IN) | 29 | Northern Illinois | 33 | De Kalb, IL | |
| 2001 | W | Ball State (IN) | 35 | Western Michigan | 31 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 2002 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Missouri | 41 | Columbia, MO | |
| 2002 | W | Ball State (IN) | 23 | Indiana St. | 21 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2002 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Clemson (SC) | 30 | Clemson, SC | |
| 2002 | W | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Connecticut | 21 | Storrs, CT | |
| 2002 | L | Ball State (IN) | 29 | Northern Illinois | 41 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2002 | L | Ball State (IN) | 17 | Toledo (OH) | 37 | Toledo, OH | |
| 2002 | W | Ball State (IN) | 42 | Eastern Michigan | 17 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2002 | L | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Bowling Green (OH) | 38 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 2002 | W | Ball State (IN) | 17 | Western Michigan | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2002 | W | Ball State (IN) | 38 | Central Michigan | 21 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 2002 | W | Ball State (IN) | 41 | Buffalo (NY) | 21 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2002 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Marshall (WV) | 38 | Huntington, WV | |
| 2003 | W | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Indiana St. | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2003 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Missouri | 35 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2003 | L | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Pittsburgh (PA) | 42 | Pittsburgh, PA | |
| 2003 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Central Michigan | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2003 | L | Ball State (IN) | 29 | Boston College (MA) | 53 | Chestnut Hill, MA | |
| 2003 | W | Ball State (IN) | 34 | Kent St. (OH) | 17 | Kent, OH | |
| 2003 | L | Ball State (IN) | 3 | Miami (OH) | 49 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2003 | W | Ball State (IN) | 38 | Toledo (OH) | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2003 | L | Ball State (IN) | 23 | Northern Illinois | 48 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 2003 | L | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Western Michigan | 28 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 2003 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Eastern Michigan | 38 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 2003 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Bowling Green (OH) | 41 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2004 | L | Ball State (IN) | 11 | Boston College (MA) | 19 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2004 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Purdue (IN) | 59 | West Lafayette, IN | |
| 2004 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Missouri | 48 | Columbia, MO | |
| 2004 | W | Ball State (IN) | 41 | Western Michigan | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2004 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Toledo (OH) | 52 | Toledo, OH | |
| 2004 | L | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Eastern Michigan | 31 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2004 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Bowling Green (OH) | 51 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 2004 | L | Ball State (IN) | 23 | Akron (OH) | 35 | Akron, OH | |
| 2004 | L | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Northern Illinois | 38 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2004 | W | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Central Florida | 17 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2004 | L | Ball State (IN) | 40 | Central Michigan | 41 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 2005 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Iowa | 56 | Iowa City, IA | |
| 2005 | L | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Bowling Green (OH) | 40 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2005 | L | Ball State (IN) | 3 | Auburn (AL) | 63 | Auburn, AL | |
| 2005 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Boston College (MA) | 38 | Chestnut Hill, MA | |
| 2005 | W | Ball State (IN) | 60 | Western Michigan | 57 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 2005 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Toledo (OH) | 34 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2005 | L | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Ohio | 38 | Athens, OH | |
| 2005 | W | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Northern Illinois | 17 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 2005 | W | Ball State (IN) | 23 | Akron (OH) | 17 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2005 | W | Ball State (IN) | 26 | Eastern Michigan | 25 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 2005 | L | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Central Michigan | 31 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2006 | W | Ball State (IN) | 38 | Eastern Michigan | 20 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2006 | L | Ball State (IN) | 23 | Indiana | 24 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2006 | L | Ball State (IN) | 28 | Purdue (IN) | 38 | West Lafayette, IN | |
| 2006 | L | Ball State (IN) | 24 | North Dakota St. | 29 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2006 | L | Ball State (IN) | 28 | Northern Illinois | 40 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2006 | W | Ball State (IN) | 55 | Buffalo (NY) | 25 | Buffalo, NY | |
| 2006 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | Central Michigan | 18 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 2006 | L | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Western Michigan | 41 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2006 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Miami (OH) | 17 | Oxford, OH | |
| 2006 | L | Ball State (IN) | 26 | Michigan | 34 | Ann Arbor, MI | |
| 2006 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Toledo (OH) | 17 | Toledo, OH | |
| 2006 | W | Ball State (IN) | 30 | Kent St. (OH) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2007 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Miami (OH) | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2007 | W | Ball State (IN) | 38 | Eastern Michigan | 16 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 2007 | W | Ball State (IN) | 34 | Navy (MD) | 31 | Annapolis, MD | |
| 2007 | L | Ball State (IN) | 40 | Nebraska | 41 | Lincoln, NE | |
| 2007 | W | Ball State (IN) | 49 | Buffalo (NY) | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2007 | L | Ball State (IN) | 38 | Central Michigan | 58 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2007 | W | Ball State (IN) | 35 | Western Kentucky | 12 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2007 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Western Michigan | 23 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 2007 | L | Ball State (IN) | 17 | Illinois | 28 | Champaign, IL | |
| 2007 | L | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Indiana | 38 | Bloomington, IN | |
| 2007 | W | Ball State (IN) | 41 | Toledo (OH) | 20 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2007 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Northern Illinois | 21 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 2007 | L | Ball State (IN) | 30 | Rutgers (NJ) | 52 | Toronto, ON (Canada) | International Bowl |
| 2008 | W | Ball State (IN) | 48 | Northeastern (MA) | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2008 | W | Ball State (IN) | 35 | Navy (MD) | 23 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2008 | W | Ball State (IN) | 41 | Akron (OH) | 24 | Akron, OH | |
| 2008 | W | Ball State (IN) | 42 | Indiana | 20 | Bloomington, IN | |
| 2008 | W | Ball State (IN) | 41 | Kent St. (OH) | 20 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2008 | W | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Toledo (OH) | 0 | Toledo, OH | |
| 2008 | W | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Western Kentucky | 7 | Bowling Green, KY | |
| 2008 | W | Ball State (IN) | 38 | Eastern Michigan | 16 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2008 | W | Ball State (IN) | 45 | Northern Illinois | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2008 | W | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Miami (OH) | 16 | Oxford, OH | |
| 2008 | W | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Central Michigan | 24 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 2008 | W | Ball State (IN) | 45 | Western Michigan | 22 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2008 | L | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Buffalo (NY) | 42 | Detroit, MI | MAC Championship Game |
| 2008 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Tulsa | 45 | Mobile, AL | GMAC Bowl |
| 2009 | L | Ball State (IN) | 10 | North Texas | 20 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2009 | L | Ball State (IN) | 16 | New Hampshire | 23 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2009 | L | Ball State (IN) | 17 | Army (NY) | 24 | West Point, NY | |
| 2009 | L | Ball State (IN) | 30 | Auburn (AL) | 54 | Auburn, AL | |
| 2009 | L | Ball State (IN) | 30 | Toledo (OH) | 37 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2009 | L | Ball State (IN) | 19 | Temple (PA) | 24 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 2009 | L | Ball State (IN) | 17 | Bowling Green (OH) | 31 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2009 | W | Ball State (IN) | 29 | Eastern Michigan | 27 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 2009 | L | Ball State (IN) | 17 | Ohio | 20 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2009 | L | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Northern Illinois | 26 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 2009 | L | Ball State (IN) | 3 | Central Michigan | 35 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2009 | W | Ball State (IN) | 22 | Western Michigan | 17 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 2010 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Southeast Missouri St. | 10 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2010 | L | Ball State (IN) | 23 | Liberty (VA) | 27 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2010 | L | Ball State (IN) | 13 | Purdue (IN) | 24 | West Lafayette, IN | |
| 2010 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Iowa | 45 | Iowa City, IA | |
| 2010 | W | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Central Michigan | 17 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 2010 | L | Ball State (IN) | 16 | Western Michigan | 45 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2010 | L | Ball State (IN) | 38 | Eastern Michigan | 41 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2010 | L | Ball State (IN) | 24 | Toledo (OH) | 31 | Toledo, OH | |
| 2010 | L | Ball State (IN) | 14 | Kent St. (OH) | 33 | Kent, OH | |
| 2010 | W | Ball State (IN) | 37 | Akron (OH) | 30 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2010 | W | Ball State (IN) | 20 | Buffalo (NY) | 3 | Buffalo, NY | |
| 2010 | L | Ball State (IN) | 21 | Northern Illinois | 59 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2011 | W | Ball State (IN) | 27 | Indiana | 20 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 2011 | L | Ball State (IN) | 7 | South Florida | 37 | Tampa, FL | |
| 2011 | W | Ball State (IN) | 28 | Buffalo (NY) | 25 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2011 | W | Ball State (IN) | 48 | Army (NY) | 21 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2011 | L | Ball State (IN) | 6 | Oklahoma | 62 | Norman, OK | |
| 2011 | L | Ball State (IN) | 0 | Temple (PA) | 42 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2011 | W | Ball State (IN) | 23 | Ohio | 20 | Athens, OH | |
| 2011 | W | Ball State (IN) | 31 | Central Michigan | 27 | Muncie, IN | |
| 2011 | L | Ball State (IN) | 35 | Western Michigan | 45 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 2011 | W | Ball State (IN) | 33 | Eastern Michigan | 31 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 2011 | L | Ball State (IN) | 38 | Northern Illinois | 41 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 2011 | L | Ball State (IN) | 28 | Toledo (OH) | 45 | Muncie, IN |